Las Vegas Sun

September 23, 2014

Currently: 74° — Complete forecast | Log in | Create an account

Utilities:

Why do you pay what you do for power?

Image

Steve Marcus

Smart meters hang on a rack at the NV Energy meter shop Tuesday, March 6, 2012.

Sun coverage

NV Energy surprised the nation last week with an announcement that it’s divesting from coal and investing in natural gas and renewable energy.

While many applauded the move away from coal, the announcement also spurred criticism that it would precipitously raise rates.

How legislative action has affected energy bills has been in the spotlight recently, after Public Utilities Commissioner David Noble fired a broadside at the Legislature for passing renewable energy mandates that he says are driving up rates.

But renewable energy advocates — including many lawmakers — say such investment will deliver lower rates over time and will help the environment and health of Nevadans.

So who’s really to blame for high rates?

Nevadans already pay nearly the highest power rates in the Mountain West region. The $104.10 average monthly bill comes in second only to Arizona, where residents pay an average of $118.62 per month.

(A different estimate specifically for Southern Nevada puts the average monthly bill at $149.24.)

So what’s driving energy costs in this state?

Here are the five big factors affecting your power bill:

    • Cheap natural gas



      The bulk of your power bill comes from a simple equation: the going rate for power multiplied by how much energy you use.

      The average Nevadan doesn’t use a lot of energy, partially because Nevadans have scrimped during the recession and have used less power. In fact, Nevada ranks 41st in the nation in energy usage.

      But Nevadans pay more than the average American for the energy they do use. Nevada has the 18th highest energy rate in the nation.

      Still, it could be worse.

      Cheap natural gas has kept rates down,” said Dan Jacobsen, consumer advocate for the Attorney General’s Bureau of Consumer Affairs.

      Because Nevada gets two-thirds of its energy from cheap natural gas, energy costs have come down even as NV Energy has increased other costs.

      But it’s arguably too good to be true. Articles about a “natural gas bubble” abound. If something happens to spark a spike in natural gas prices — if the bubble pops — Nevada energy customers could be in trouble.

      “We’re so overleveraged on natural gas,” said Assemblyman David Bobzien, D-Reno, who chairs the Assembly Commerce and Labor committee. “If we’re not doing enough on renewable energy, then we’re really going to be caught.”

    • Paying more for using less



      Energy costs for Southern Nevada customers have increased in 2011 and 2012 because of a new law that allows NV Energy to recover money for its energy efficiency programs.

      More efficient appliances, light bulbs and windows, as well as other programs that allow you to use less energy, come at a cost because the utility charges all ratepayers for the energy you’re not using.

      “They get to charge customers for the sales that they didn’t make,” Jacobsen said. “The cost of subsidizing the energy efficiency, whether it's light bulbs or more efficient air conditioners, is a cost ratepayers had to bear.”

      The practice of using less and paying more began following the passage of a bill in 2009.

      (It’s the “Energy Efficiency” charge on your bill.)

      NV Energy argues that the efficiency charge costs ratepayers less than what it would cost for the utility to either buy or generate the electricity that would be needed to meet the demand absent the efficiency programs.

      “Efficiency has historically been both the cheapest and cleanest way to meet customer energy needs and to meet the Nevada renewable standard,” NV Energy spokesman Rob Stillwell said.

      Bottom line, an analysis from the Public Utilities Commission shows that this charge accounts for about 4 percent of the average bill, or $5.68.

    • Renewable energy mandates



      Commissioner Noble said last month that NV Energy customers are “maxed out” on various mandates the Legislature passes.

      Several of these mandates include renewable energy programs.

      The state’s “Renewable Portfolio Standard” requires the utility to buy renewable energy, even when it’s not the most cost-effective means to provide energy to ratepayers.

      The state also mandates charges for renewable energy subsidies and development. They comprise a percentage of your overall bill.

      The Public Utilities Commission estimates that renewable energy mandates accounted for about 4.1 percent of the average bill in Southern Nevada last year.

      That’s $5.83 a month.

    • NV Energy construction costs



      In two broad categories, the utility can either buy power from a third party or own and operate power plants.

      NV Energy has invested in the latter, adding 3,700 megawatts of gas-fired generation in the past decade, said Bob Johnston, a lawyer representing renewable energy companies in Nevada. Of that, 1,800 megawatts are in Southern Nevada, according to the company.

      So while energy costs have been decreasing because of cheap natural gas, the utility’s construction and operations expenses have increased, meaning rates have remained relatively flat during the past five years.

      The upshot for the utility’s shareholders is that the utility collects a return on its construction investment.

      That’s good for shareholders. NV Energy doubled its year-over-year profit in 2012.

      “Utilities make money by building stuff,” said Luke Busby, a renewable energy lobbyist, at a hearing April 1. “They receive a return on equity for a system they built.”

      The utility company has spent about $2.4 billion during the past 10 years. This is a cost that ratepayers pay for, with interest.

    • Franchise fees and energy assistance programs



      Local governments charge a flat “franchise” fee to you, the ratepayer. Local governments also charge the utility company a fee to do business in their jurisdictions, a cost that is passed on to ratepayers.

      The other fee you will likely see on your bill is the “UEC” charge, or Universal Energy Charge, which gets deposited into a state fund for energy assistance for low-income Nevadans.

      It’s a fixed charge that hasn’t changed during the past five years for NV Energy customers. It comprises 0.3 percent of an average bill while the local government fee totals about 5 percent of the average bill.

      Bottom line, these two charges combined add about $7.53 to the average bill, according to a Public Utilities Commission analysis.

    Join the Discussion:

    Check this out for a full explanation of our conversion to the LiveFyre commenting system and instructions on how to sign up for an account.

    Full comments policy

    Previous Discussion: 10 comments so far…

    Comments are moderated by Las Vegas Sun editors. Our goal is not to limit the discussion, but rather to elevate it. Comments should be relevant and contain no abusive language. Comments that are off-topic, vulgar, profane or include personal attacks will be removed. Full comments policy. Additionally, we now display comments from trusted commenters by default. Those wishing to become a trusted commenter need to verify their identity or sign in with Facebook Connect to tie their Facebook account to their Las Vegas Sun account. For more on this change, read our story about how it works and why we did it.

    Only trusted comments are displayed on this page. Untrusted comments have expired from this story.

    1. How about #6? Government "feel-good" mandates that drive up our costs?

    2. If you look at the price per KWH Nevada is a bit lower than the national average.

      The national avg. is 11.47 cents per KWH. Nevada avg. is 11.24 cents per KWH.

      Basing on usage to make up the total bill is a bit deceiving since some people use more than others.

      Look at California, they are paying an avg. of 16.40 cents per KWH.

      On avg. though states that have high requirements for power from renewable sources pay about 2 cents per KWH than states that have no renewable requirements.

    3. Only the middle class, hard-working segment of Nevadans are supporting or subsidizing the rest of the state. WHY does a monopoly utility that holds the public hostage, have the right to sell shares for profit? It should be a non-profit if it is a sole vendor of power, or water, not an agency set on making a profit on the backs of helpless citizens who have NO other choice!

      As far as being a consumer of power or water here in Clark County, I just about unplugged, and stopped watering any and everything at my home here. It is a terrible way to live. Still, the utilities go UP, while my paycheck hasn't for over 5 years of public service---no costs of living adjustments. Many, as myself, have to take on second jobs to make up for the difference. Such does NOT attract folks and businesses to move into Nevada. Someone needs to keep that in mind....

      Blessings and Peace and wishing for a wind generator,
      Star

    4. #6: failed attempt at deregulation in the late 1990s and early 2000s. Before this major screw up we were at 6.7c instead of 12.

      For context, Michael Yackira annual total compensation per NV Energy's annual report filed with the Securities and Exchange commission.

      2008: $3.7M
      2009: $4.5M
      2010: $5.4M
      2011: $7.7M
      2012: $6.5M

      Raise your hands, fellow commenters, if your total compensation more than doubled from 2008-2011. Anyone? Bueller? Bueller?

    5. One of those feel-good mandates mentioned above is the Universal Energy Charge on our power bills--that's where they get the state match to the federal LIHEA program--which is giving illegal households free utilities of about $1,100 a year while American seniors are cold and hungry. LIHEA in Nevada is given to larger households and "families" of fewer than four people generally don't get a dime. So our little old ladies trying to live on $888 a month in SS are subsidizing heating and cooling for illegals. The illegals get free EBT/SNAP, housing vouchers, dominate food bank groceries, drive Escalades, work off the books, have numerous anchor babies to preclude ICE activity....

    6. We need to renegotiate the contract for power from Hoover Dam! California is stealing our power and our water from Lake Mead. Soon, we won't have either.

    7. How much conserving and investment in energy star appliances do you think those getting free utilities bother with?

    8. A PUD (Public Utility District) is needed here to assure rate payers that their money is spent on energy, without having to support a "private enterprise" that enjoys monopoly status here.

    9. YUP. No thanks to our special-needs state legislature, NVE can charge whatever-the-hell they want for power. Aren't monopolies sort of illegal??

    10. NV Energy profits are protected thanks to the legislature. They gave NVE the right to increase rates to cover and losses due to energy saving and the PUC has to uphold the law. Guess who wrote the law the legislature passed?